Call 844-GET-1600

6 Test Prep Misconceptions Tutors Wish Every Family Understood

Two students can receive  the same number of SAT or ACT prep hours and get very different results. The difference usually comes down to each family’s expectations going in.

This month, a Facebook group of independent test prep tutors asked its members a simple question: what do you wish customers understood before working with you? About two dozen test prep professionals answered. Some answers were about content, but most were about expectations, and the same few points came up again and again.

Here are the six test prep misconceptions those professionals described, why each one costs students points, and how to overcome them. Each one is a reasonable thing for a parent to believe. Each one also leads to a weaker plan.

1. "A 32 is an average ACT score"

The average ACT Composite for the Class of 2026 was 19.2, and the median was 18, according to ACT's 2026 National Profile Report. About 4% of the 1.46 million graduates who tested scored 32 or higher. For tests taken since September 2025, the Composite is the average of English, math, and reading, with science reported separately.

The national figure includes students in states where all juniors take the ACT on a school day, so most college-bound South Florida students should aim above 19. Still, a 32 is a top-4% score. A family that treats it as the baseline will read a 27 as a disappointment when it may be an excellent result for that student.

Set the targets from the student's goals. For Florida families, the first target number is set by Bright Futures, the state scholarship that covers 75% to 100% of tuition and fees at Florida public colleges and universities. The Florida Medallion Scholars award requires a 24 ACT or 1190 SAT for the Class of 2027, rising to 25 or 1200 for the Class of 2028. Florida Academic Scholars requires a 29 ACT for both classes, or a 1330 SAT for the Class of 2027 and 1350 for the Class of 2028, according to the Bright Futures program guide. Both awards also have GPA and service-hour requirements. The second target number is the mid-point of the middle 50% score range of accepted students at the colleges on the student's list. Those two numbers give a family a real target.

2. "A 4.0 means a 30+ is on the way"

Grades and test scores line up less often than they used to. In a July 2026 research report on grade inflation, ACT found that a growing share of students have grades substantially higher than their test scores would predict. By 2023-24, about 4 in 10 ACT test takers no longer reported a GPA at all. After estimating the missing GPAs, ACT put the share of students whose grades outpaced their scores at about 28%, up from about 9% a decade earlier. The mismatch was strongly associated with schools that showed more grade inflation.

That is not a criticism of the student. A 4.0 means the student met each teacher's expectations. It does not show whether the student retained Algebra II from sophomore year or can read a dense passage under time pressure. Several tutors in the poll made this point, and it is the one parents find hardest to hear.

We wrote about this gap in our post on why a high GPA doesn't always reflect academic readiness. The practical step is a full-length, timed diagnostic before anyone sets a score goal. The GPA reflects school course results. The diagnostic measures where the student stands on this test.

3. "Test prep is about tricks"

One tutor put it this way: there are no tricks on the SAT, only traps. The test writers build wrong answers that look right to a student who is rushing or who only partly knows about the traps.

Strategy helps a student avoid those pitfalls. It does not replace the geometry, algebra, and punctuation rules the student forgot or never learned. In our experience, a student scoring in the low 20s on ACT math, or below about 550 on SAT math, usually has a content gap, and pacing strategies do not fix content gaps. That student needs to review the underlying material first, sometimes in academic tutoring, before formal test prep begins.

The work that raises scores is often unglamorous: comma rules, exponent rules, and the vocabulary a strong reader builds from years of reading. Families who expect steady skill-building tend to see the gains they were hoping for.

4. "We're paying for the hours, so the hours will raise the score"

This theme came up repeatedly, in different words. Attendance matters, but most of the improvement comes from the practice a student does between sessions.

The clearest public data on practice comes from the College Board. In a 2017 study of about 250,000 students who took the paper SAT, those who completed about 20 hours of Official SAT Practice, the College Board's free program on Khan Academy, gained an average of 115 points from the PSAT to the SAT. That was nearly double the gain of students who did not use it. The study was correlational – motivated students practice more, which is the point: the gains followed the students' own work.

Our own numbers point the same way. Of the data we've collected, we've seen 80% of our students experience a 150-point SAT gain or more. I would not want any parent to read that as a promise. Students who do the in-session work, complete the homework, and apply the strategies we teach see gains. A tutor can teach, diagnose, and hold a student accountable. The commitment has to come from the student.

This is also why reputable tutors do not offer score guarantees. The student takes the test. The tutor does not. A guarantee usually means repeat sessions or a refund with conditions attached, and neither tells you much about the instruction. Instead, ask a tutor how she tracks progress, what improvement typically looks like for students starting where yours is, and how many hours of practice a week she expects between sessions.

5. "A few sessions right before the test should do it"

Tutors in the poll shared requests like these: two sessions to take an ACT English score from 24 to 30, or a practice SAT, a practice ACT, and a two-session package, all over one holiday week.

A six-point gain on an ACT section is possible. It typically takes weeks of instruction and practice, spaced out so the skills stick, with official practice tests along the way to measure progress. A short burst of sessions makes a student more familiar with the format and produces little lasting improvement. If the test date is only a few weeks away and the goal is a large gain, moving to a later test date is often the better choice.

Setting that schedule is part of a tutor's job: how often to meet, what to cover in which order, and when the student is ready for the real test. Our ACT prep and SAT prep programs start with a diagnostic and build the plan backward from the test date, which is why we encourage families to start months ahead.

6. "Any smart tutor will do"

This was my answer to the poll: tutors are not a commodity.

A cousin who aced college calculus may be brilliant. Knowing how the SAT tests linear functions, which wrong answers students pick and why, and how to rebuild a student's confidence after a bad practice test is a different skill. Experienced test prep tutors have seen hundreds of students make the same errors, and they recognize the pattern in the first session.

Price per hour is the easiest number to compare and the least useful one. The better comparison is what the total investment produces: how the tutor diagnoses, how they adjust when a student stalls, and how they report progress to the family. One tutor's 10 hours can accomplish more than another's 30. That is why we match each student with a tutor for private SAT tutoring based on the diagnostic, the student's schedule, and the score goal.

How to avoid these test prep misconceptions before you hire a tutor

Families who get the most from test prep tend to do four things first:

  • Take a full-length, timed diagnostic for both the SAT and the ACT, and compare the results.

  • Set a target from the Bright Futures thresholds and the middle 50% ranges at the student's colleges.

  • Start at least three to four months before the intended test date.

  • Ask the tutor how many hours of practice a week to expect, and put those hours on the family calendar.

Do those four things before the first session, and the hours you pay for will go toward raising the score.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a good ACT score?

A good ACT score is one that meets the student's goals, such as a Bright Futures threshold or the middle 50% range at their target colleges. For context, the national average Composite for the Class of 2026 was 19.2, and about 4% of test takers scored 32 or higher, according to ACT's 2026 National Profile Report.

Does a high GPA mean my child will score well on the SAT or ACT?

A high GPA does not guarantee a high test score. ACT's July 2026 research estimated that about 28% of students in the 2023–24 cohort had grades substantially higher than their ACT scores would have predicted, after accounting for students who did not report a GPA. A timed diagnostic test shows where a student stands before a goal is set.

How many hours of SAT or ACT prep does a student need?

Most students need several months of consistent work, including practice between sessions. A 2017 College Board study of the paper SAT found that students who completed about 20 hours of Official SAT Practice gained an average of 115 points. Gains depend on the student's practice and homework, not only the hours spent with a tutor.

Should I choose an SAT tutor who guarantees a score increase?

A score guarantee is a poor way to choose a tutor, because the result depends on the student's effort and performance on test day. A better approach is to ask how the tutor diagnoses weaknesses, tracks progress, and adjusts the plan when a student stalls, and how much practice they expect each week between sessions.

Is it too late to start test prep a few weeks before the SAT or ACT?

A few weeks of prep can help a student get comfortable with the format, but large score gains usually take several months of spaced practice. If the test date is close and the goal is a big increase, moving to a later test date often gives the student a better result.

Score At The Top Learning Centers & Schools has been helping Florida families build strong academic foundations for over 40 years. To learn more, visit scoreatthetop.com.

Showing 164 colleges

College or University State First-Quarter Grades
Agnes Scott CollegeGAUsed if sent
Alfred UniversityNYUsed if sent
Allegheny CollegePAUsed if sent
American UniversityDCUsed if sent
Amherst CollegeMARequired
Assumption UniversityMAUsed if sent
Babson CollegeMARequired
Barnard CollegeNYRequired
Bates CollegeMERequired
Bennington CollegeVTRequired
Bentley UniversityMARequired
Boston UniversityMARequired
Bowdoin CollegeMERequired
Brandeis UniversityMARequired
Brown UniversityRIRequired
Bryant UniversityRIUsed if sent
Bryn Mawr CollegePAUsed if sent
Bucknell UniversityPARequired
California Institute of TechnologyCARequiredRestrictive EA
Carleton CollegeMNUsed if sent
Carnegie Mellon UniversityPAUsed if sent
The Catholic University of AmericaDCUsed if sent
Centre CollegeKYUsed if sent
Champlain CollegeVTUsed if sent
Chapman UniversityCAUsed if sent
Christopher Newport UniversityVAUsed if sent
Claremont McKenna CollegeCARequired
Clark UniversityMARequired
Clarkson UniversityNYUsed if sent
Colby CollegeMEUsed if sent
Colgate UniversityNYUsed if sent
College of CharlestonSCUsed if sent
College of the AtlanticMERequired
College of the Holy CrossMARequired
Columbia UniversityNYRequired
Connecticut CollegeCTRequired
Dartmouth CollegeNHRequired
Davidson CollegeNCRequired
DePauw UniversityINUsed if sent
Denison UniversityOHUsed if sent
Dickinson CollegePARequired
Drexel UniversityPAUsed if sent
Duke UniversityNCRequired
Earlham CollegeINUsed if sent
Elon UniversityNCUsed if sent
Emerson CollegeMARequired
Emmanuel CollegeMAUsed if sent
Fairfield UniversityCTUsed if sent
Flagler CollegeFLUsed if sent
Fordham UniversityNYUsed if sent
Furman UniversitySCUsed if sent
Georgetown UniversityDCUsed if sentEA
Gettysburg CollegePARequired
Grinnell CollegeIAUsed if sent
Grove City CollegePAUsed if sent
Hamilton CollegeNYRequired
Hampden-Sydney CollegeVAUsed if sent
Harvard UniversityMAUsed if sentEA
Harvey Mudd CollegeCARequired
Haverford CollegePARequired
High Point UniversityNCUsed if sent
Hillsdale CollegeMIUsed if sent
Hobart and William Smith CollegesNYUsed if sent
Illinois Institute of TechnologyILUsed if sent
Iona UniversityNYUsed if sent
Ithaca CollegeNYUsed if sent
The Jewish Theological SeminaryNYRequired
Johns Hopkins UniversityMDUsed if sent
Juniata CollegePAUsed if sent
Kalamazoo CollegeMIUsed if sent
Kenyon CollegeOHRequired
Lafayette CollegePARequired
Lake Forest CollegeILUsed if sent
Lawrence UniversityWIUsed if sent
Lehigh UniversityPAUsed if sent
Lewis & Clark CollegeORRequired
Loyola Marymount UniversityCAUsed if sent
Loyola University MarylandMDUsed if sent
Macalester CollegeMNRequired
Manhattan UniversityNYUsed if sent
Marist UniversityNYUsed if sent
Merrimack CollegeMAUsed if sent
Middlebury CollegeVTRequired
Monmouth UniversityNJUsed if sent
Mount Holyoke CollegeMARequired
Muhlenberg CollegePARequired
Nazareth UniversityNYUsed if sent
New York UniversityNYUsed if sent
Northwestern UniversityILUsed if sent
Oberlin CollegeOHRequired
Occidental CollegeCARequired
Ohio Wesleyan UniversityOHUsed if sent
Pomona CollegeCARequired
Princeton UniversityNJRequiredRestrictive EA
Providence CollegeRIUsed if sent
Quinnipiac UniversityCTUsed if sent
Randolph-Macon CollegeVAUsed if sent
Reed CollegeORUsed if sent
Rensselaer Polytechnic InstituteNYRequired
Rhodes CollegeTNUsed if sent
Rice UniversityTXUsed if sent
Rochester Institute of TechnologyNYUsed if sent
Sacred Heart UniversityCTUsed if sent
St. John's CollegeMD, NMRequired
St. Lawrence UniversityNYUsed if sent
St. Mary's College of MarylandMDUsed if sent
St. Olaf CollegeMNUsed if sent
Salisbury UniversityMDUsed if sent
Salve Regina UniversityRIUsed if sent
Sarah Lawrence CollegeNYRequired
Scripps CollegeCAUsed if sent
Siena UniversityNYUsed if sent
Skidmore CollegeNYRequired
Smith CollegeMARequired
Springfield CollegeMAUsed if sent
Stanford UniversityCAUsed if sentEA
Stevens Institute of TechnologyNJUsed if sent
Stonehill CollegeMARequired
Susquehanna UniversityPAUsed if sent
Swarthmore CollegePARequired
Sweet Briar CollegeVAUsed if sent
Syracuse UniversityNYUsed if sent
Texas Christian UniversityTXUsed if sent
Transylvania UniversityKYUsed if sent
Trinity CollegeCTRequired
Trinity UniversityTXUsed if sent
Tufts UniversityMARequired
Tulane UniversityLAUsed if sent
Union CollegeNYRequired
University of ChicagoILUsed if sent
University of Mary WashingtonVAUsed if sent
University of MiamiFLUsed if sent
University of New HavenCTUsed if sent
University of Notre DameINRequiredRestrictive EA
University of PennsylvaniaPAUsed if sent
University of Puget SoundWAUsed if sent
University of Rhode IslandRIUsed if sent
University of RichmondVARequired
University of RochesterNYUsed if sent
University of San DiegoCAUsed if sent
University of San FranciscoCAUsed if sent
University of ScrantonPAUsed if sent
University of Southern CaliforniaCAUsed if sent
University of VermontVTUsed if sent
University of VirginiaVAUsed if sent
Utica UniversityNYUsed if sent
Vassar CollegeNYRequired
Wabash CollegeINUsed if sent
Wake Forest UniversityNCUsed if sent
Warren Wilson CollegeNCUsed if sent
Washington & Jefferson CollegePAUsed if sent
Washington University in St. LouisMORequired
Washington and Lee UniversityVAUsed if sent
Webb InstituteNYRequired
Wellesley CollegeMARequired
Wentworth Institute of TechnologyMAUsed if sent
Wesleyan UniversityCTRequired
Wheaton CollegeMARequired
William & MaryVAUsed if sent
Williams CollegeMARequired
Wofford CollegeSCUsed if sent
Worcester Polytechnic InstituteMARequired
Yeshiva UniversityNYUsed if sent
York College of PennsylvaniaPAUsed if sent

Lists compiled by Francis "Cigus" Vanni for the 2026-27 application cycle. Confirm current requirements on each college's admissions website.

What seniors applying early should do now

Your first quarter is already on the record. Here is who sees it, and what comes next.

  • Confirm first-quarter grades were sent and received. If your ED school is on the required list, ask your counselor how and when the grades went out, then check the applicant portal. Counselors track dozens of different college requirements, and a short note naming the college and its policy helps.

  • Ask about used-if-sent schools before deciding anything. Many high schools send first-quarter grades for all early applicants as a matter of policy, so the choice may not be yours. If it is, our advice is to send them when they show an upward trend or strong marks in your hardest courses. Holding back a weaker quarter only delays it: counselors send mid-year and final reports to the school where you enroll.

  • Treat the second quarter as the next read. A deferred ED applicant moves into the Regular Decision pool, and the Mid-Year Report is often the newest academic evidence in that file.

  • Protect the final transcript. An ED admission assumes the student finishes senior year at the level shown in the application, and colleges can rescind offers when final grades fall sharply.

  • If your ED school is not on the list, check its admissions website. Policies change, and the college's own page is the final word.

The second quarter is where early applicants most often slip. The weeks between ED submission and winter break are when seniors who relaxed after filing tend to fall behind in coursework. If a grade is sliding in a demanding course, academic tutoring during the second quarter costs far less than a weak Mid-Year Report. Florida students weighing the new binding programs can also read how we're advising families on ED to UF or FSU.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do colleges look at first-quarter senior grades for Early Decision?

Yes, at many selective colleges. In Cigus Vanni's 2026-27 lists, 59 colleges require first-quarter grades from early applicants (56 for Early Decision I and three restrictive Early Action schools), and another 105 will use them if a counselor submits them. Readers use these grades to confirm that a student is handling a demanding senior schedule.

Does Duke require first-quarter grades for Early Decision?

Yes. Duke University is on Vanni's required list for the 2026-27 cycle, along with Brown University, Columbia University, Dartmouth College, Tufts University, Boston University, and Washington University in St. Louis. Ask your counselor to send first-quarter grades as soon as they post, then confirm receipt in the applicant portal.

How do I send first-quarter grades to colleges?

Your high school counselor sends them. Counselors usually submit an updated transcript or progress report through the Common App, SCOIR, or Naviance, or send it to the admissions office directly. The Common App does not remind counselors to send these reports, so ask your counselor and then confirm receipt in the college's applicant portal.

What happens if my senior-year grades drop after I apply Early Decision?

Readers will see it, either on the first-quarter report or later on the Mid-Year and final reports. A decline in core or AP courses can lead to a deferral, a request for an explanation, or, after admission, a rescinded offer. Talk to your counselor about whether context belongs in the file, and work to bring the grade up before the semester ends.

Do Harvard, Stanford, and Princeton want first-quarter grades for Early Action?

Princeton University does; Harvard University and Stanford University do not require them but will use them if submitted. Princeton runs single-choice Early Action and sits on Vanni's required list with California Institute of Technology and the University of Notre Dame. Georgetown University, like Harvard and Stanford, will use first-quarter grades if sent.

Grade slipping in a senior-year course? Score At The Top Learning Centers & Schools has helped Florida students with tutoring and academic coaching for more than 40 years. Weighing Early Decision strategy or planning after a deferral? JRA Educational Consulting advises families on early-round strategy, deferrals, and final college choices.


Lists compiled by Francis "Cigus" Vanni for the 2026-27 application cycle. College names have been standardized to full official names. Confirm current requirements on each college's admissions website.

Next
Next

Which Colleges Require First-Quarter Grades for Early Decision? The 2026-27 List